Refusal to Provide a Breath Sample Lawyer

Failing or refusing to comply with a breath or blood demand is a distinct offence from impaired driving itself, and it depends heavily on exactly what the officer said and did at the roadside. As a experienced lawyer, Mtre Sevag Abrahamian reviews how the demand was communicated, whether it was legally valid, and whether the person understood what was being asked.

Every consultation is confidential.

What a Refusal to Provide Breath Sample Lawyer Reviews

Under section 320.15 of the Criminal Code, the offence requires that a person knowingly failed or refused, without reasonable excuse, to comply with a valid demand made under the roadside screening or evidentiary testing provisions. A close review by a refusal to provide breath sample lawyer examines whether the officer had the grounds required to make the demand, whether the demand itself was clearly and properly worded, whether there was any language or communication barrier, whether medical or other circumstances could amount to a reasonable excuse, and whether the sequence of events was accurately documented. Each of these elements can be significant to the outcome.

Contact us

Four Areas That Can Shape a Refusal Case

01

Validity of the Demand

Whether the officer had proper grounds and used the correct legal wording to make the demand.
02

Communication & Understanding

Whether the demand was clearly understood, including in cases involving language barriers.
03

Reasonable Excuse

Whether a medical condition or other circumstance could explain the failure to comply.
04

Timeline of Events

Whether police notes and recordings accurately reflect what was said and when.

Press coverage

In the media

Selected public reporting and official records involving Mtre Abrahamian. Each feature opens directly to its original source.

Supreme Court of CanadaSCC

His Majesty the King v. Abdel Karim Chemlal

Mtre Abrahamian has pleaded before the Supreme Court of Canada for the AQAAD and AADM interveners, as the official court record shows.

View the official court file (opens in a new tab)
Journal de MontréalJdM

A $9-million fraud prosecution

Coverage of a major Desjardins-data fraud proceeding reports on Mtre Abrahamian's sentencing submissions.

Read the coverage (opens in a new tab)

Coverage published by

Selected Cases About Refusal Defence

Insights

Inside The Law

Explore All Articles

FAQs

About Refusal Defence

Explore All FAQs

No. Failure or refusal to comply with a demand under section 320.15 of the Criminal Code is a separate offence from impaired operation under section 320.14. It can be charged whether or not there is any other evidence of impairment, and it is prosecuted and defended differently.

A reasonable excuse generally requires a genuine physical or medical inability to comply, such as a documented respiratory condition preventing a valid breath sample, rather than a simple unwillingness or inconvenience. Whether specific circumstances meet this threshold depends on the facts of the case.

Whether a demand was properly understood, including in cases involving a language barrier or unclear wording by the officer, can be significant to the defence. If the demand was not clearly communicated, it may affect whether the refusal was knowing and deliberate as the offence requires.

Yes. An administrative licence suspension can apply separately from the criminal charge and is generally handled through the SAAQ’s own process, distinct from the outcome of the criminal proceedings.

We’re Here to Help

A Criminal Defence Attorney for Your Legal Matter

Facing a criminal or penal matter can bring serious questions and uncertainty. Contact Abrahamian & Associates Lawyers to discuss your situation and the legal representation available to you.

  • Confidential Consultation
  • Service in English and French
Preferred Language